Wednesday 18 November 2026 15:11
Italy’s Antisemitism Bill Becomes Law
The vote divides the opposition, with Democratic Party reformists breaking ranksItaly has a new law against antisemitism. On Tuesday 17 November, the Chamber of Deputies gave its final approval to the bill, with 147 votes in favour, 93 against and 5 abstentions. The Senate had already passed the text in March, and the Chamber approved it without changes, so it now becomes law.What the law doesThe law officially adopts the working definition of antisemitism of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), including its explanatory examples. Some of those examples refer to the State of Israel. It does not create new criminal offences, because existing laws, such as the Mancino law on hate crimes, already cover this area. Instead, it sets up a National Coordinator for the fight against antisemitism at the Prime Minister’s office, and provides for a three-year national strategy and a databank to monitor antisemitic incidents and hate crimes.Who voted howThe centre-right majority, Italia Viva and Azione voted in favour. The Five Star Movement, the Greens and Left Alliance (AVS) and most of the Democratic Party (PD) voted against, along with Futuro Nazionale, the group of Roberto Vannacci, which opposed the bill from the right on the grounds that it conflicts with freedom of expression.The PD’s position was the most closely watched. The party confirmed its vote against, but its reformist wing did not follow the line. Piero Fassino spoke in dissent and said he would abstain, with some colleagues. In the Senate, several of these reformists, including Graziano Delrio and Lorenzo Guerini, had voted in favour. The five abstentions were the PD’s.
The argument over IsraelThe opposition argues that the IHRA examples risk blurring the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel’s government. AVS’s Filiberto Zaratti called the bill a “bavaglio” (gag) on critics of Israel. M5S’s Alfonso Colucci said failing to distinguish between antisemitism and anti-Zionism “harms the fight against the first.” Amnesty International has shared concerns about limits on criticism of Israel. The PD, M5S, AVS and +Europa proposed adopting the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism instead, but the government and rapporteur Paolo Emilio Russo opposed it and the amendments were rejected.
The majority says that fear is unfounded. Russo told the chamber that “no one in this chamber ever dreamed of limiting the right of political criticism”. Augusta Montaruli of Fratelli d’Italia said the centre-right was willing to seek a unanimous vote, on the single condition that the IHRA definition not be changed. Supporters also point out that the definition was endorsed in 2017 by Elly Schlein, then a member of the European Parliament, and in 2020 by the Conte government. Mauro Del Barba of Italia Viva said antisemitic incidents had quadrupled in three years. The Union of Italian Jewish Communities (UCEI) welcomed the law.
The debate in the chamber was tense. Exchanges over Gaza led to shouting, and several deputies were called to order, including the PD’s Gianni Cuperlo and Enzo Amendola. Liliana Segre, the Holocaust survivor and senator for life, had asked for a shared text, possibly with changes. That appeal was not heeded.
The law does not set a deadline for appointing the coordinator, adopting the strategy or creating the databank.
Ph: Civic Lens / Shutterstock.com
#news #legal affairs
read the news on Wanted in Rome - News in Italy - Rome's local English news
Italy has a new law against antisemitism. On Tuesday 17 November, the Chamber of Deputies gave its final approval to the bill, with 147 votes in favour, 93 against and 5 abstentions. The Senate had already passed the text in March, and the Chamber approved it without changes, so it now becomes law.The law officially adopts the working definition of antisemitism of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), including its explanatory examples. Some of those examples refer to the State of Israel. It does not create new criminal offences, because existing laws, such as the Mancino law on hate crimes, already cover this area. Instead, it sets up a National Coordinator for the fight against antisemitism at the Prime Minister’s office, and provides for a three-year national strategy and a databank to monitor antisemitic incidents and hate crimes.The centre-right majority, Italia Viva and Azione voted in favour. The Five Star Movement, the Greens and Left Alliance (AVS) and most of the Democratic Party (PD) voted against, along with Futuro Nazionale, the group of Roberto Vannacci, which opposed the bill from the right on the grounds that it conflicts with freedom of expression.
The PD’s position was the most closely watched. The party confirmed its vote against, but its reformist wing did not follow the line. Piero Fassino spoke in dissent and said he would abstain, with some colleagues. In the Senate, several of these reformists, including Graziano Delrio and Lorenzo Guerini, had voted in favour. The five abstentions were the PD’s.
The opposition argues that the IHRA examples risk blurring the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel’s government. AVS’s Filiberto Zaratti called the bill a “bavaglio” (gag) on critics of Israel. M5S’s Alfonso Colucci said failing to distinguish between antisemitism and anti-Zionism “harms the fight against the first.” Amnesty International has shared concerns about limits on criticism of Israel. The PD, M5S, AVS and +Europa proposed adopting the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism instead, but the government and rapporteur Paolo Emilio Russo opposed it and the amendments were rejected.
The majority says that fear is unfounded. Russo told the chamber that “no one in this chamber ever dreamed of limiting the right of political criticism”. Augusta Montaruli of Fratelli d’Italia said the centre-right was willing to seek a unanimous vote, on the single condition that the IHRA definition not be changed. Supporters also point out that the definition was endorsed in 2017 by Elly Schlein, then a member of the European Parliament, and in 2020 by the Conte government. Mauro Del Barba of Italia Viva said antisemitic incidents had quadrupled in three years. The Union of Italian Jewish Communities (UCEI) welcomed the law.
The debate in the chamber was tense. Exchanges over Gaza led to shouting, and several deputies were called to order, including the PD’s Gianni Cuperlo and Enzo Amendola. Liliana Segre, the Holocaust survivor and senator for life, had asked for a shared text, possibly with changes. That appeal was not heeded.
The law does not set a deadline for appointing the coordinator, adopting the strategy or creating the databank.
Ph: Civic Lens / Shutterstock.com
